As for as ride quality, my "stretched" setup of Falken ST115 225/35s on Work 19x8.5s/19x9s is extremely comfortable. Maybe it's my APEXi WS coilovers that help make the ride comfortable while being low, but the OP has Teins so his shouldn't be much different.
I agree that the OP should do enough research to know what he's getting himself into, but if there's a certain look he's wanting there's only a minimal amount of options he has. Work Meisters need a decent width & offset in order to look right due to their spoke design (they're made for the aggressive look in my eyes).
Haha, we'll agree to disagree on that one. I personally don't find a stretched 225/35 on a 9" to be too comfortable for my 45 minute, pot hole ridden commute, but maybe I am just too old...
I was actually referring to lilphotoman's setup in particular, with my comments and his is a 225 stretched on a 9.5. I will never doubt that it looks cool, it just wouldn't be my 1st choice for a DD, (but you are right about the meisters, they do need to be wide/low offset.)
IMHO the best looking offsets that don't too much stretch or too much fender work, are:
18x8 +30 (Milan's 350Z wheels)
18x8.5 +37
18x9 +40 (stretched)
18x9 +45
You could push it a little bit further for a more aggressive look, but i think these have a pretty nice balance.